Strategy What is an insight?

Illustrator: Ihar Turtsou
We work in an industry laced with buzzwords [...]

Design Forgiving a pretty face

In the late spirit of Valentine’s day, I’ve been thinking [...]

Digital Responsivenessicity

Illustrator: Bailey Bremmers (Design Apprentice)
A few years ago it [...]

Culture #GripLabLive – Elias Theodorou

Grip Associate Partner and MMA fan Ben Weinberg sat down [...]


Big Orange Slide

Saturday, April 18th, 2015

Over connected, under engaged

January 19, 2012 by Sylvie Chicoine

Illustration by Josiah Bilagot

Editor’s note: It’s also Sylvie’s birthday today. Enjoy her article, and round out your brilliant comments with some birthday greetings!

By now you may have heard the talk about how engagement levels on brand pages on Facebook are steadily declining. Ad Age reported in Q3 last year that engagement on the Facebook walls of leading brands is down 22%; a scary thought for marketers who are finally comfortable with the platform and are investing more dollars into Facebook apps and community management than ever before.

Many theories exist to try to explain this decline. Some say it’s due to inherent behavioural shifts; others blame it on the idea that Facebook users are jumping ship onto the shiny new Google+ platform. The reality is that Facebook activity overall in Canada is not declining. In fact, Canadian brand pages get 70M+ new fans each month, according to a source from Facebook Canada. So what’s the problem here?

The problem is that many community managers (the person or people responsible for the daily maintenance of the Facebook brand page) are not truly communicating with their fans; many community managers only respond to fans when spoken to and they don’t take advantage of what fans are really saying to them and to each other. This kind of flaky relationship with a brand on Facebook is what leads to declining engagement rates and, eventually, what will cause a brand’s fan count to go down. To reverse this trend, community managers can put an end to superficial dialogue and mine their fans for relevant content.

I’ve seen many brand pages move towards a more effective communication style on Facebook by ending the wall-as-broadcast-channel method and instead using more relevant and relatable wall posts. For example, moving from “[ExampleKitchenBrand] can solve all of your kitchen problems” to “what is your favourite meal to make for Sunday dinner?” Asking fans about what they like and what matters to them in a context that connects to the brand is one way to build a better relationship with fans and should naturally lead to higher engagement.

Another way to maintain or increase engagement levels is to put an end to superficial dialogue. I often see community managers responding directly to fans’ wall posts on brand pages only when it involves answering product-related questions or as a general “thank you” for leaving a comment on the page. This kind of speak-when-spoken-to conversation is superficial and can hardly be considered as proactive communication. The community manager for ExampleKitchenBrand, for instance, can build stronger relationships and a stronger community by making recipe recommendations to individual fans who they know like gourmet nachos or by connecting a group of fans who they know are all interested in cheese graters. These are just a couple of examples of how really knowing your community and putting an end to superficial dialogue can give your Facebook page a boost.

Being that connected to the community also allows community managers to put what their fans are saying to better use. Community managers have a key role as the person with the closest relationship with their best, most loyal customers. Community managers are uniquely positioned to listen to what fans are saying, identify trends, and act on that information. For example, the community manager for [ExampleKitchenBrand] may notice that there is a lot of chatter about pancakes on the wall, identify a trend with flavour infusions and berries, and filter that trend back to the content creation team who can start developing new pancake recipes. This kind of activity allows the group to develop content and messaging that truly meets the needs and interests of their fans and, in turn, increases engagement levels on the brand page.

When it comes down to it, community managers need to treat their fans like they would treat their friends and do more than simply hear and respond. They must become active listeners, interpret and evaluate what their fans are saying, and give their fans what they want and need. Following some of these basic systems of communication means community managers will never be without inspiration for content and, best of all, the brand page will keep fans engaged.

2 Comments on "Over connected, under engaged"

  • Rodion Rogov
    January 19, 2012 @ 9:07 pm

    80% of projects fail due to poor communication management,so this comes as no surprise. As some points were given for community managers, they can really be taken to a wider audience for whom the advertising is produced. Most younger individuals, myself included, have their thoughts in technology and interactive platforms, however we are really trying to derive a human interest in ourselves and a human interaction from these pieces of hardware. The companies community manager being able to listen to the audience is key to the amount of engagement there is. When I got to launch OKA’s twitter and relaunch their facebook page, having communication as close to human was one of the main points stressed, as it shows that one is interested in the customer and willing to listen and spend their time on these events. You are essentially are the human interface for the company through various interactive platforms.

    P.S. One of the main ways humans learn is through repetition. What we have learned by clicking like on facebook for example is that it goes away if I click this button. This is in my professional opinion and is drawn on no statistical data, but since we have been clicking “like” or signing up for a email, every time we did so, the amount of engagement we felt goes down. Now that we know that to engage a human in a digital world, we need to simulate emotional connection through an interface of lights, text and buttons. How do we go about engaging an individual through physical actions?

  • Ken Easson
    January 21, 2012 @ 5:08 am

    really excellent article! Treat consumers as if they are people interested in quality products not as revenue generating statistics.

    Would there be value in suggesting that we should re-name “community managers” as “digital engagement associates”. Personally i don’t like to be “managed” which is kinda how it seems when i read meaningless replies that often suggests the one who hit the “send pre-generated message #8″ key hadn’t bothered to properly read what the poster was saying.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.